Dish
Key Lime Pie

Photo from
The Canadian (VIA Rail) · Vancouver
The story
Key Lime Pie is a classic American dessert defined by its tart, creamy filling and crumbly crust. Its origins are traced to the Florida Keys in the late 19th century, where local Key limes were abundant. The dessert is believed to have been created by "Aunt Sally," a cook for a sponge-fishing magnate, who used sweetened condensed milk—a staple before refrigeration—to thicken the juice of the small, aromatic limes. The pie is traditionally made with a graham cracker crust, a filling of egg yolks, sweetened condensed milk, and Key lime juice, and is often topped with a meringue or whipped cream.
A great version achieves a perfect balance: a filling that is firm yet silky, intensely tart but tempered by sweetness, and a crust that is buttery and crisp. The use of authentic Key limes, which are more floral and acidic than Persian limes, is crucial for the signature flavor.
Regional variations exist, with some bakers in the Florida Keys insisting on a meringue topping, while others prefer a dollop of whipped cream. At **Joe's Stone Crab** in Miami Beach, the pie is a celebrated staple, praised by *Jack's Dining Room* for its classic execution. The restaurant’s version, often served with a cloud of meringue, is a testament to the dessert’s enduring appeal and its deep connection to South Florida’s culinary identity.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review.
Where to eat it
4 places reviewed by YouTube creators.
What creators say
Highlights from 4 creator reviews of Key Lime Pie.
The Canadian offers a luxury sleeper train experience across Canada with comfortable cabins, excellent dining, and breathtaking views. Despite some cleanliness issues and delays, the overall experience is incredible and worth the price.
The most famous Cuban restaurant in Miami, a cultural institution where locals and tourists alike come for Cuban classics like vaca frita, Cubano, and oxtail stew, with a coffee window that started a citywide trend.
Versailles · MiamilovedGianni's is the place to be seen in Miami, with a lively atmosphere right by the pool, but the tables are very close together making it hard to film. The food was pretty good, especially the chicken paillard and key lime pie, though dinner and a Coke cost $71.
Joe's Stone Crab is a historic Miami institution with massive stone crab claws and surprisingly affordable, excellent fried chicken, plus a top-tier key lime pie.



