Dish
Triple Play Plate

Photo from
Make My Fish · New York
The story
The Triple Play Plate is a composed dish that has gained prominence in New York City, particularly at the seafood-focused venue **Make My Fish**. As highlighted by the food review series *Jack's Dining Room*, the plate is celebrated for its balanced, multi-textural approach to seafood preparation. While the exact origins of the name are debated, the "triple" typically refers to a trio of distinct preparations or protein components served on a single plate, offering a curated tasting experience.
A great version of the Triple Play Plate is distinguished by the quality and contrast of its three elements. These often include a crispy fried filet, a tender grilled or blackened portion, and a raw or cured component, such as ceviche or crudo. The key is achieving textural diversity—crunchy, flaky, and silky—while ensuring each preparation highlights the freshness of the fish. The dish is typically finished with complementary sauces, pickled vegetables, or a light salad to cut through the richness.
Regional variations are emerging as chefs reinterpret the concept. In coastal areas, the plate might feature local catches like snapper or halibut, while inland versions may substitute shellfish or even non-seafood proteins. Some restaurants offer a "surf and turf" twist, replacing one seafood element with a meat component. The Triple Play Plate’s appeal lies in its versatility and the skill required to execute three distinct cooking methods harmoniously, making it a benchmark for a chef’s technical range.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review.
Where to eat it
1 place reviewed by YouTube creators.
New York (1)
What creators say
Highlights from 2 creator reviews of Triple Play Plate.
Make My Fish in Harlem serves incredibly flavorful fried seafood, with a giant fried fish sandwich and a massive Triple Play plate that are both seasoned to the max.
Make My Fish in Harlem serves incredible fried seafood and surprisingly excellent fried chicken, with the Triple Play plate being a massive, flavorful deal.
