The story
Located on 8th Avenue in Midtown, New York Pizza Supreme serves as a reliable, accessible neighborhood staple for those seeking a classic New York-style slice. The menu focuses on familiar favorites, including the Cheese Slice and the Meat Lover slice, catering to locals who value convenience over culinary innovation.
While the venue maintains a solid 4.6-star rating, recent reviews suggest the experience can be inconsistent. Creator Giovanni Fois, who visited the shop for a regional pizza comparison, acknowledged its historic reputation but ultimately awarded it a 7/10. Fois noted that the Cheese Slice was "too salty" and found the Meat Lover slice to be "unbalanced." While the shop remains a convenient option for a quick bite, its execution may struggle to stand out in the city's highly competitive pizza landscape.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review. First reviewed 2025.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 2 dish mentions say about the food
Giovanni Fois praises the cheese pizza as a masterclass in simplicity, with a perfectly blistered crust and rich, milky mozzarella. The overall vibe is one of unpretentious, high-quality execution that elevates a classic.
“The cheese is sweet, but the tomato sauce is very salty. There's a strange contrast. The dough is full-bodied, but I'm left with a salty aftertaste. The slice of mozzarella isn't the best. Overall it's pleasant, I'd eat it without problems, but it's a bit too salty. I'd give it a 7 out of 10 max.”
What creators say
1 creator has covered New York Pizza Supreme. Most active: Giovanni Fois
- Giovanni FoisMixed
HO PROVATO LE 3 PIZZE MIGLIORI D'AMERICA - CHICAGO VS NEW YORK VS DETROIT · @ 4:00
New York Pizza Supreme is a historic, famous slice joint in New York, but I found the cheese slice too salty and the Meat Lover unbalanced — overall pleasant but not great.
Dishes mentioned
Cheese Pizza
The cheese is sweet, but the tomato sauce is very salty. There's a strange contrast. The dough is full-bodied, but I'm left with a salty aftertaste. The slice of mozzarella isn't the best. Overall it's pleasant, I'd eat it without problems, but it's a bit too salty. I'd give it a 7 out of 10 max.
Meat Lover Pizza
This one has sausage, what looks like bacon, and spicy salami. It's like the first one on steroids, but it's too unbalanced. It had potential to be better than Pops, but it's not. I'd give it a 7 out of 10.
