The story
Tucked into a small Long Beach grocery store, Sorrento’s holds an almost perfect 4.8 rating and a quiet reputation for artisan pizza made from fresh, handmade ingredients. When Dave Portnoy of One Bite Pizza Reviews stopped by, the owner begged him to keep the place secret, pleading that the family-run spot “couldn’t handle a crowd.” Portnoy’s resulting video, titled “Forget About This High Score,” awarded a high score but came with that warning.
That plea is both the heart and the tension of Sorrento’s: a handmade, sincere hidden gem overwhelmed by its own success. For now, the best way to enjoy it might be to respect the owner’s request—even if that’s nearly impossible once word gets out.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review. First reviewed 2026.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 1 dish mentions say about the food
Sorrento’s pizza earns rave reviews for its perfectly charred crust and fresh toppings, with One Bite Pizza Reviews calling it a standout. The overall vibe is warm, unpretentious, and deeply satisfying—a true neighborhood gem.
“This pizza is handmade, cooked by the owner himself, with all super fresh ingredients. One bite, everyone knows the rules — it's really good. I'd give it an 87, but you never heard that from me. Don't come here, though.”
What creators say
1 creator has covered Sorrento's. Most active: One Bite Pizza Reviews
- One Bite Pizza ReviewsLoved
Pizzeria Owner Swears Dave Portnoy To Secrecy, So Forget About This High Score · @ 0:02
Sorrento's in Long Beach serves artisan pizza that's handmade with fresh ingredients, but the owner begs people not to come because it's a small family place that can't handle crowds.
Dishes mentioned
Pizza
This pizza is handmade, cooked by the owner himself, with all super fresh ingredients. One bite, everyone knows the rules — it's really good. I'd give it an 87, but you never heard that from me. Don't come here, though.
