The story
At Tony’s New York Pizza in Hanau, the star attraction isn’t a slice—it’s a chocolate chip cookie. Dave Portnoy of One Bite Pizza Reviews gave it an 87, calling it “worth coming just for the cookies.” That singular rave stands out on a menu otherwise unremarked by critics, and it’s the only dish anyone has bothered to single out.
The restaurant itself holds a modest 3.8-star average, suggesting a solid but unremarkable experience overall. Yet Portnoy’s enthusiasm suggests the cookie alone is reason enough for a detour—a sweet spot that punches well above the venue’s broader reputation. If you’re in Hanau, skip the pizza and head straight for the dessert.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review. First reviewed 2026.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 1 dish mentions say about the food
“That is a sharp looking chocolate chip cookie. I asked the guy, 'Do you make the cookies here?' He said, 'I'm not going to lie. We do.' I saw these chocolate chip cookies and said, 'Holy Dave. Get involved.' Cookie is worth the price of admission. I know a good cookie. I saw that cookie and I go, you fuck. 87 on the cookie. Cookie is spectacular. Straight out of the oven. They do make it there. Eight. Seven. I'll come here just for the cookies.”
What creators say
1 creator has covered Tony's New York Pizza. Most active: One Bite Pizza Reviews